Why Won’t My Lashes Stay Curled?

Why Won’t My Lashes Stay Curled

Curled lashes can make all the difference in your appearance, making you look more awake and really giving your eyes that crucial definition. However, sometimes we don’t have the best of luck and even genetics for that matter, to keep the perfect curl. So, in reference to this puzzling and frustrating situation, today we ask the question, why won’t my lashes stay curled?

Reasons Why My Eyelashes Don’t Stay Curled

There are several reasons your eyelashes aren’t staying curled. For one thing, you simply may not be genetically created to have ‘curled lashes.’ As silly as it may seem, some people have a more naturally malleable lash shape. Straight lashes make it harder for any product, curler, or heat treatment, to stay on the lash.

Furthermore, your lashes may be damaged from the previous over-treatment. Lashes actually serve an essential purpose for humans, going back to before cave-dwelling days. Lashes have evolved to keep the damaging sun from directly hitting our eyes, like small eyelid umbrellas.

Eyelashes are meant to take on the elements. Yet, they are still delicate structures, which could find themselves withering off your eyes if abused.

‘Abused,’ in this context means they’ve been agitated. When you overtreat lashes, they become brittle and break. One product that damages the lashes is water-proof mascara due to the harsh chemicals that are used to form the moisture-wicking formula. Also, new research shows these chemicals contain cancer-causing agents.

Another lash stressor is heating treatments for longer curl holds. Despite notorious hacks online that tout their curl-holding ability, putting heat on lashes, using tools such as a hair dryer, can damage your lashes if applied too often or at too high a temperature.

In addition to waterproof mascara, applying too many layers of mascara on the eyes can cause them to be weighed down. Don’t trust all those tutorials from the early 2010s that recommend five layers of ‘volume-enhancing’ mascara. It’s not working if it takes five coats. Repeated usage of this technique can prevent curls instead.

You could also be using your eyelash curler the wrong way. Though this is an easily avoided reason for eyelashes not staying curled, it can make quite the difference in how long a curl lasts. Curling the lash in one movement doesn’t properly structure the lash. In fact, it’s more like pulling on it in an upward direction, rather than setting a curl.

What Causes Straight Eyelashes?

Although there’s nothing at all wrong with having straight lashes, it’s a frustrating factor when curling lashes. Straight lashes are a genetic trait that originates from a lack of double eyelid creases. Instead, this genetic trait develops a monolid that causes the lashes to grow straight down.

How Do I Make My Eyelashes Stay Curled?

There are many solutions on the web that claim to be amazing hacks for flat lashes and some actually work, while others may leave you with bald eyelids, hence why you should always prioritize safety first.

A great way to improve the curl’s longevity is to use two separate mascaras. Formulas for mascaras do indeed make a difference and finding two to three different options that work for you is great as you can combine between looks. The best combination is to use one mascara for length and another for volume.

Use your curler properly. Whether it’s trying to pull the lashes upward, or clenching down too hard, there are many ways you can inappropriately use a curler. Instead, you should press down on the lashes in three separate sections, starting from the lash line all the way to the ends, making sure to pulse on each section gently.

Just like the effectiveness of eyebrow gel, putting a waxy substance on lashes can make a significant difference. Though there are clear eyelash gels that are pre-packaged and ready for application, you can also use vaseline as an alternative.

Other options include Aquaphor, Egyptian Magic, and Glossier’s Balm Dotcom. Simply apply a thin layer to the lashes and then curl. This method is also great as it allows the eyelashes to remain malleable and moisturized.

Why Won’t My Lashes Stay Curled

Despite the dangers of using and overusing heat treatments on the lashes, there are some safe methods of doing so. Specifically, hover your hair dryer over your eyelash curler, wait thirty seconds and then press the curler against the lashes.

You can even purchase a heated curler that can preheat to a safe temperature. It’s best to test the temperature on your fingers or arm hair, but when done correctly and safely, it can increase the longevity of a curl all day long.

However, this method shouldn’t be used every day, as it can damage lashes when used frequently.

One solution you might consider a bit weird involves a spoon. It might be everyone’s cup of tea and takes some dexterity, but it has been proven to work. Simply heat a spoon in some hot water, then bring it up to your eye line with the curved side facing towards the lashes.

Using your thumb and index finger, press the spoon against the lashes and hold for ten-second on each eye. This method is probably more suited for emergency lash lifts, but it’s always good to have a hack when in need. Otherwise, of course, an eyelash curler is always the best choice.

Why Do My Eyelashes Go Down When I Apply Mascara?

Having eyelashes that go down when mascara is applied is a rather confusing and contradictory experience. However, sinking eyelashes can be the result of applying too many layers of product to the lashes, which is why it is best to stick to one to two layers only.

Furthermore, the formula of the mascara could be too thick for your specific lashes, but it’s actually more likely that there’s too much product on the brush, causing clumping on the lashes.

To fix this problem, twist the brush back and forth in the tube in circular motions. In addition, if you aren’t using a curler before applying mascara, the mascara itself won’t be sufficient in keeping a curl. If the lashes aren’t properly prepared before application, you’re merely sticking the product onto flat lashes.

Why Eyelashes Won’t Stay Curled with Mask

With recent and ongoing events, wearing a mask hasn’t been the best for keeping curly lashes intact. Usually, one of the main culprits of depleted lashes is humidity.

The oxygen being breathed in the mask has only one direction to go and that’s up, towards your lashes. To solve this problem, use a combination of eyelash clear gel, such as vaseline, and your usual mascara.

This, along with inevitable touch-ups throughout the day, will keep your lashes looking curly and luscious.

Best Eyelash Curlers to Use

1. Sephora Collection Lash Curler and Fuser

Sephora Collection Eyelash Lash Curler, Lash Fuse And Curl
Check Price on Amazon

This fantastic curler is a two-in-one. Not only does it curl your lashes with a soft, silicone lining, but it can also easily connect the real lashes with your falsies. Its uniform shape allows for easy application on all eye shapes and eyelash types.

Furthermore, its aesthetic profile is made of nickel, making it extremely hypoallergenic on the skin.

2. Panasonic Heated Eyelash Curler with Comb Design

Panasonic Heated Eyelash Curler Comb With Non-Stick Silicone, Wand-Style - EH2351AC
Check Price on Amazon

As an alternative to your everyday eyelash curler, here is one option that will definitely change the game. This curler not only comes with a built-in temperature-controlled heater but also a sleek and unique comb design, specifically built to glide along the lashes and give a long-lasting curl with just two swipes. In addition, this well-crafted beauty tool is entirely reusable, with a battery charged feature and an ability to be rinsed with only water.

3. Tweezerman Champagne Every Lash Curler

Tweezerman Every Lash Curler Model No. 1070-R
Check Price on Amazon

Okay, so although this curler’s deceiving appearance is a bit daunting, given that it looks exactly like a nail clipper, it’s always better to not judge a book by its cover.

In fact, this curler is anything but a clipper. Its small clamps allow you to access difficult-to-reach lashes that would otherwise stick out amongst longer and curled strands. It’s also fantastic for blending the finite line between falsies and your natural lashes.

4. Preo Prima Shogyo Japanese Partial Eyelash Curler

Preo Prima Shogyo Japanese Partial Eyelash Curler | Inner Corner/Outer Corner Precision Lash Curl Up tool | Made In Japan (Included 2 Replacement Rubber) | C-180
Check Price on Amazon

Much like the Tweezerman, this curler is perfect for hard-to-get lashes but is also even more efficient at assisting straight lashes. Its compact design allows for the lash to be curled in sections, so you definitely know it won’t miss from corner to corner.

5. Lancome Le Curler

Lancome Le Curler Effortless Lash Design Eyelash Curler Eyelash Curler
Check Price on Amazon

Finally is this wonder from Lancome. Perfect for long-lasting shape, its rounded clamp design covers a range of eye shapes. Plus, even after a few pulses, this curler ensures a natural-looking, yet long-lasting curl, without unnecessary flare; great for everyday and on-the-go use.


From what we’ve mentioned, there’s always going to be one if not several factors at play when it comes to keeping your lashes in check, so you don’t have to keep wondering why won’t my lashes stay curled. The great thing is, most of these problems have effective solutions.

However, what matters when it comes to achieving curls is a combination of trial and error, safety, and finally, a look you’re satisfied with.

Recent Posts